By Jedidiah McKeehan
jed@attorney-knoxville.com
You have a terrible experience with a business, so you pull out your phone and leave a one-star review. A few days later, the business threatens to sue you for defamation unless you delete it. Can someone really sue you over a Google, Facebook, or Yelp review?
Yes. Anyone can file a lawsuit. Whether the business can win is a very different question. A defamation claim generally requires a false statement of fact that was published to someone else and damaged a person’s or business’s reputation.
A substantially true statement is generally protected. An honest opinion based on disclosed facts is also much safer than a factual accusation you cannot prove. Saying, “I waited ninety minutes after my scheduled appointment,” describes an event. Saying, “This business steals from every customer,” accuses the business of criminal conduct and may be difficult to defend without real evidence.
Simply adding the words “in my opinion” does not create a magic shield. “In my opinion, the owner committed fraud” still sounds like a factual claim that fraud occurred. Reviews are safest when they stick to your own experience, use accurate dates and amounts, avoid unnecessary exaggeration, and preserve receipts, photographs, messages, and other support.
Tennessee also has the Tennessee Public Participation Act, a law designed to allow the early dismissal of weak lawsuits targeting protected speech on matters of public concern. The statute specifically includes speech about goods, products, and services in the marketplace. If a lawsuit is dismissed under the Act, the court must award the successful party reasonable attorney’s fees and costs.
In 2024, the Tennessee Supreme Court applied that law in Charles v. McQueen, a case involving a critical Google review connected to a residential development dispute. The Court dismissed the defamation and false-light claims because the person suing was a limited-purpose public figure and had not shown that the reviewer acted with actual malice.
That does not mean every harsh review is protected or that defending a lawsuit will be painless. Before posting, take out the insults, check every factual statement, and say exactly what happened. A calm, specific review is usually more credible to readers and much easier to defend in court.
Jedidiah McKeehan is an attorney practicing in Knox County and surrounding counties. Visit attorney-knoxville.com for more information about this legal issue and other legal issues.